This error addresses the nature of what an eternal, uncreated book is supposed to be versus what Surah 63 actually is.
Surah 63:8:
They say, 'If we return to Al-Madinah, the more honored will surely expel therefrom the more humble.' But to Allah belongs all honor, and to His Messenger, and to the believers...
Islamic theology claims the Quran is a copy of an eternal tablet preserved in heaven since before creation. Yet, Verse 8 is purely reactive—it is a direct, real-time response to a specific insult uttered by a 7th-century tribal chief (Abd-Allah ibn Ubayy) during a single military campaign (the expedition of Banu Mustaliq).
Elevating petty, localized tribal insults and playground political squabbles into an eternal divine text represents a foundational inconsistency with the concept of a timeless, universal message.